Showing posts with label graphic narratives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label graphic narratives. Show all posts

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Amulet: The Stonekeeper

Spoiler Alert!: Most of the big reveals in this story are given away in this review.
by Courtney Hilden

Amulet: The Stonekeeper is the first book in a graphic novel series that follows Emily and her brother Navin as they struggle to rescue their mom, who has been taken by a tentacled monster. Despite the overly-used premise and nods to other fantasy stories, this first part of the Amulet story manages to feel fresh.
The story opens up on a family vacation, one that ends in tragedy after a car crash kills Emily and Navin's father. Because of his death, their mother moves them both to their ancestral home, which has an opening to a mystical world that Great-Grandfather Silas (still somehow alive) was running with the help of an amulet. Similar to the titled ring in The Lord of the Rings, the amulet's power comes with serious, personal drawbacks, but to save her mother, Emily decides to wield its power. Great-grandfather's gang of helpers, including a bunny-like Misket, help Emily and Navin, and the story ends before readers can know if their mom survives.
The artwork is stunningly cinematic, especially in their color choices and background detail. The monsters feel new, with a strangely combination of the Halloween ghouls of Invader Zim and the many characters, good and bad, from Hayao Miyazaki. The children, Emily and Navin, are perfect cartoon characters, both simple and expressive. (The series is now in the process of being made into a movie, and given the fantastic art, this is not surprising.)
It is also nice that the main hero is Emily and not a young man. So often in fantasy stories that are written for both genders the hero is male. Often, female characters play small roles or ones that confine them to feminine roles (as mothers, nurturers, or even in Avatar: The Last Airbender, where the main female character, despite considerable power, was the one doing most of the cooking and laundry.) Here, Emily is a character who is without an disadvantage that could be coded as "womanly." She is tying to save her last living parent and take care of her younger brother, a role that could have easily been male, but here, thankfully, is not. It is time both young girls and boys read a story about a real girl, one who is brave and well-intentioned but imperfect, and this looks like a great series to do so with.

Friday, April 22, 2011

Terror Trips


Spoiler Alert!: Some of the endings to these short stories are revealed in this review
by Courtney Hilden

Terror Trips is a collection of three Goosebumps stories done as graphic narratives. "One Day at Horrorland" chronicles a family's misadventures at a theme park, "Deep Trouble" is about a boy visiting his scientist uncle and meeting a mermaid, and "A Shocker on Shock Street" is about two kids trying out a new theme park ride.
Each story stands up at least reasonably well within the graphic narrative (or as the kids would probably read these call them, comics.) There is plenty of action and monsters to make each story fun.
The two stories for "Deep Trouble" and "One Day at Horrorland" are predictable. "Deep Trouble" has the hero, Billy, comes to the inevitable conclusion that the mermaid, captured for scientific study and confinement, should be released. "One Day at Horrorland" is slightly less predictable, with the children remembering a detail about the theme park that leads them to the discover the weakness of the monsters that are about to kill them. It is the sort of detail that seems to obvious in retrospect. In terms of the storyline, the impressive one is "A Shocker on Shock Street," which has an impressive Twilight Zone-esque ending. The story starts out with the assumption that the two children are completely normal, but in the end, it turns out they were like their father's other creations: robots meant to emulate something else. The ending was well-handled, fast, and devastating.
The art work for "Deep Trouble" is particularly beautiful. The artist, Amy Kim Ganter, created an adorable mermaid, one that I would love to follow in further adventures. The artwork for the other two stories was serviceable for the story but not as eye-catching as Ganter's work.